# GA4 Setup Checker

> Free self-audit of a GA4 setup: 14 yes/no/not-sure questions, a weighted score out of 100 and a list of likely gaps, each with a link to where to read more.

Source: https://sterling.company/ga4-setup-checker · Machine-readable spec: https://sterling.company/ga4-setup-checker/spec.json · Publisher: Sterling Lab

## Short answer

The GA4 Setup Checker is a free self-audit of whether you can rely on your GA4 numbers. You answer 14 yes, no or not-sure questions and get a score out of 100 and a list of likely gaps, biggest first, each with a link to where to read more. It connects to nothing and reads nothing from GA4, and your individual answers are not sent anywhere.

The weights and band cut-offs are our own definitions, not a benchmark.

## How the score works

Each check has a weight of 1, 2 or 3. Yes earns the full weight, Not sure earns half, No earns nothing. A check marked not applicable is left out of both sides of the sum.

**score = round((sum of weights answered yes + 0.5 × sum of weights answered not sure) ÷ sum of weights of the applicable checks × 100). A check answered na is left out of both sums.**

The checks with weight 3 are core checks. A no or not sure on any of them keeps the band out of solid, even when the score is 80 or higher.

The list of gaps is sorted by points lost, biggest first: a No loses the full weight of the check, a Not sure loses half of it. Checks that lose the same number of points keep the order in which they are listed below.

## Bands

- **80 to 100**: Solid on paper. The remaining items are tidy-up work. Next step: Fix the remaining items when convenient, then re-run the check before a budget change and after a site, form or tag change.
- **50 to 79**: Gaps worth fixing. Some GA4 numbers may be counted twice, credited to the wrong source or never checked. A failed or unconfirmed core check holds you here even with a score of 80 or more. Next step: Start with the first item in the list. If a core check is named, look at that one before anything else.
- **0 to 49**: Hard to trust. Fix the top items before you change budgets. Next step: Do not change campaign budgets on the strength of GA4 yet. Fix the top items, then run the check again.

## Worked example

A business that sells nothing online marks the purchase check as not applicable (“No online sales”), which leaves 25 of the 27 points in play. A test form submission arrives twice in GA4, so “One submission, one event” is No. The agency that set GA4 up left no notes, and nobody on the team can say whether a UTM convention, the Google Ads link and the internal-traffic filter are in place, so those three are Not sure. Everything else is Yes.

Use Not sure only when you really cannot tell. If you know a check is missing, answer No.

1. Applicable weight: 27 − 2 = 25
2. Points lost: 3 + 1 + 1 + 0.5 = 5.5, so earned is 25 − 5.5 = 19.5
3. Score: 19.5 ÷ 25 × 100 = 78
4. Band: 78 is in 50 to 79, so gaps worth fixing
5. Gaps in order: One submission, one event (3 points lost); One documented UTM convention (1); Google Ads is linked and imports the events you trust (1); Your own visits are filtered out (0.5)

Steps to compute any result: remove not-applicable checks from the total; lose the full weight for each No and half for each Not sure; earned = applicable weight − points lost; score = round(earned ÷ applicable weight × 100); then apply the band and core rules; sort the gaps by points lost, biggest first.

## The 14 checks (27 points in total)

### Events and conversions

**Key events match your written list of real conversions** (weight 3, core)

- Question: You have written down, in plain words, what a real conversion is for your business (a submitted quote form, a call, a paid order), and the key events marked in GA4 match that list.
- How to check: GA4 Admin → Events (or Key events): write what each marked event means in real life, then compare with your list. A button click, a scroll or a thank-you page view counted next to a real lead is a mismatch.
- If No or Not sure: GA4 may count activity as wins. Our GA4 audit guide describes owners who find a button click or a scroll counted next to a real lead, so the total looks healthy while real inquiries are flat. The reverse also happens: the one event that matters was never turned on.
- Guide: [A GA4 audit you can finish in one afternoon](https://sterling.company/guides/ga4-audit)

**One submission, one event** (weight 3, core)

- Question: One form submission or one order produces exactly one event in GA4, not two or more.
- How to check: Submit your own test form or place a test order, then open GA4 Realtime or DebugView and count the events that arrive for it.
- If No or Not sure: One action may be counted several times. Our GA4 audit guide lists duplicate firing as a red flag: a single form fill that shows up twice or more. Our service page describes the order case: a thank-you page tag and a server-side tag that both fire purchase.
- Guide: [A GA4 audit you can finish in one afternoon](https://sterling.company/guides/ga4-audit)

**A test conversion seen arriving** (weight 2)

- Question: After the last change to the site, forms or tags, someone placed a test order or submitted a test form and watched it arrive in GA4 under the right event and source.
- How to check: GA4 → Realtime (or Admin → DebugView): complete a conversion on your site and look for the event and the source it is credited to.
- If No or Not sure: Nobody has watched a real conversion arrive. Our GA4 audit guide gives one rule before any budget change: place a test order or submit your own form and watch it arrive in the real-time report. If you cannot find your own test, do not trust anyone else’s.
- Guide: [A GA4 audit you can finish in one afternoon](https://sterling.company/guides/ga4-audit)

**Purchase carries items, currency, value and a transaction ID** (weight 2)

- Question: Purchase events carry the items, the currency, the value and a transaction ID, so an order is not counted twice and revenue in GA4 can be compared with your orders.
- How to check: Open a test purchase in DebugView and check the event parameters: items, currency, value and transaction_id should all be present.
- Not applicable when: No online sales
- If No or Not sure: Purchase data may be incomplete or not de-duplicated. Our service page describes ecommerce events wired with the items array, currency, value and transaction_id de-duplication. Without them revenue cannot be matched with orders, and a second tag can repeat a purchase.
- Service: [GA4 setup, audit and repair service](https://sterling.company/services/ga4-setup)

### Traffic and sources

**Direct and Unassigned traffic checked** (weight 2)

- Question: You have looked at how much traffic GA4 credits to Direct or Unassigned, and you know the main reasons it is there.
- How to check: GA4 → Reports → Traffic acquisition: look at the Direct and Unassigned rows next to your active campaigns. Typical causes: untagged ad or email links, a payment or booking page on another domain, consent hiding visitors until they accept.
- If No or Not sure: Traffic may be sitting under no source. Our GA4 audit guide: if a large share sits under Direct or Unassigned, something is stripping the source. Each cause quietly moves credit away from the channel that earned it, so a campaign that works can look like it does not.
- Guide: [A GA4 audit you can finish in one afternoon](https://sterling.company/guides/ga4-audit)

**One documented UTM convention** (weight 2)

- Question: Paid, email and social links carry UTM tags, and one written convention (names for source, medium and campaign) is used across platforms.
- How to check: Open the links in your live ads and email tools: check for utm_source, utm_medium and utm_campaign, and compare the spelling with the convention. Auto-tagging stays on in Google Ads.
- If No or Not sure: Links may lose their source on the way to GA4. Our GA4 audit guide names ad links with no tracking parameters and email tools that do not tag their links as common causes of unlabeled traffic. Our service page puts the UTM convention first: documented and enforced across platforms.
- Guide: [A GA4 audit you can finish in one afternoon](https://sterling.company/guides/ga4-audit)

**Channel groups route Meta and Google correctly** (weight 1)

- Question: Your channel grouping puts Meta traffic under Paid Social and Google ads under Paid Search, and brand-name organic is not shown as paid.
- How to check: GA4 → Traffic acquisition with the default channel group: check which channel your Meta campaigns and Google campaigns appear in. If they land under Direct or Organic, the grouping does not understand your UTM convention.
- Not applicable when: No paid traffic at all
- If No or Not sure: Meta may be credited to Direct or Organic. Our service page describes a default channel group that does not understand your UTM convention: Meta gets credited to Direct, and brand-name organic shows up as Paid. Source and medium then say little you can rely on.
- Service: [GA4 setup, audit and repair service](https://sterling.company/services/ga4-setup)

**The visitor keeps one identity across checkout and booking domains** (weight 2)

- Question: When a visitor moves to a payment page, a booking tool or another domain of yours and comes back, GA4 keeps them in one session instead of starting a new one.
- How to check: Make a test order that leaves your domain: after the return, check in Realtime or DebugView whether the source of the conversion is your campaign or Direct.
- Not applicable when: One domain, no external pages
- If No or Not sure: A page on another domain may break the session. Our GA4 audit guide lists a payment or booking page on another domain that starts a fresh session as a common cause of lost source. Our service page calls the fix cross-domain stitching: the client ID kept across redirects, payment processors and subdomains.
- Service: [GA4 setup, audit and repair service](https://sterling.company/services/ga4-setup)

**The cookie banner passes consent to Google** (weight 1)

- Question: After a visitor accepts the cookie banner, Google’s tags receive a consent update, so GA4 is not left in the default denied state.
- How to check: Run the 90-second test from our article: DevTools → Network → filter “collect”, click Accept, check that gcs moves from G100 to G111. The Consent Mode v2 checker covers the whole chain.
- Not applicable when: No banner needed
- If No or Not sure: Consent settings may hide visitors from GA4. Our GA4 audit guide lists consent settings that hide visitors until they accept among the causes of unlabeled traffic. Our consent article describes the most common failure: the banner shows but never sends the update to Google.
- Article: [Consent Mode v2 and missing GA4 conversions](https://sterling.company/blog/consent-mode-v2-ga4-attribution-gap)

### Access and data quality

**The property is yours and you have admin access** (weight 3, core)

- Question: The GA4 property belongs to your business, and someone on your side has admin access, not only a former agency or freelancer.
- How to check: GA4 Admin → Property access management: your business login should be listed as Administrator. If only an outside login is listed, ask for access before anything else.
- If No or Not sure: Nobody on your side may control the data. Our GA4 audit guide starts with ownership and access because everything else depends on it. A property that only a former agency or freelancer can open is a red flag.
- Guide: [A GA4 audit you can finish in one afternoon](https://sterling.company/guides/ga4-audit)

**Your own visits are filtered out** (weight 1)

- Question: Visits by your team and your own testing are filtered out of the reports.
- How to check: GA4 Admin → Data collection and modification → Data streams → Configure tag settings → Define internal traffic. Then check that the filter is active, not only defined.
- If No or Not sure: Your own testing may be inflating the numbers. Our GA4 audit guide lists internal traffic as an area to check: your own testing inflates sessions and events when it is not filtered out.
- Guide: [A GA4 audit you can finish in one afternoon](https://sterling.company/guides/ga4-audit)

**Google Ads is linked and imports the events you trust** (weight 2)

- Question: GA4 is linked to Google Ads, and the conversions imported into Ads are the same events you trust in GA4.
- How to check: GA4 Admin → Product links → Google Ads links, then Google Ads → Goals → Conversions: compare the imported events with the key events you checked above.
- If No or Not sure: Ads and GA4 may disagree with no explanation. Our GA4 audit guide names an Ads report and a GA4 report that disagree with no explanation as the red flag for this check. The link has to exist, and the imported events have to be the ones you trust.
- Guide: [A GA4 audit you can finish in one afternoon](https://sterling.company/guides/ga4-audit)

### Checks against reality

**GA4 compared with your CRM, calls or orders** (weight 2)

- Question: In the last month someone compared the number of leads or orders in GA4 with a source outside it, such as your CRM, call log, booking inbox or backend.
- How to check: Take the same period in GA4 and in your own records and compare the counts. Close numbers mean GA4 is usable. A large gap means you should not spend against GA4 until you know why.
- If No or Not sure: GA4 has not been checked against anything outside it. Our GA4 audit guide ends its order of work with this step: compare GA4’s lead count with your CRM, call log or booking inbox. If the two are far apart, do not spend against GA4 until you know why.
- Guide: [A GA4 audit you can finish in one afternoon](https://sterling.company/guides/ga4-audit)

**Re-checked after changes and before budget decisions** (weight 1)

- Question: GA4 is checked again before a significant budget change and after a site redesign, a form change or a new booking tool.
- How to check: Write down the date of the last full check. The short version: ownership, key events, a test conversion, the source it was credited to, a comparison with your records.
- If No or Not sure: A working setup may have broken after the last change. Our GA4 audit guide recommends auditing before a significant budget change, after a site redesign, form change or new booking tool, and whenever the report stops matching your records. The point is to audit before a budget decision, not after it.
- Guide: [A GA4 audit you can finish in one afternoon](https://sterling.company/guides/ga4-audit)

## FAQ

**Does this connect to my Google Analytics account?**

No. It asks questions and scores your answers. Nothing is loaded from your GA4 property, Google Tag Manager, Google Ads or your site, so the result is only as good as the answers. Each question has a short note on where to look in GA4: Admin, Realtime, DebugView or Traffic acquisition.

**Why does “Not sure” count as half?**

An unknown is not a confirmed failure, but it is not a pass either: nobody is watching that check. Half the weight keeps it visible in the score and on your list. Use it only when you really cannot tell. If you know a check is missing, answer No.

**Is the score a benchmark against other properties?**

No. The weights and the 80 and 50 thresholds are our own definitions, chosen to rank what matters most for whether you can rely on GA4 numbers. They are not drawn from industry data, and the score does not compare you with anyone.

**What happens to my answers?**

They stay in your browser tab, are not sent anywhere, and disappear when you leave or start over. Our site analytics receives only an aggregate: that the check was started and finished, with the final score, the band and the number of gaps, and the score again if you click the service link. The individual answers are never sent.

**Why can a high score still stay in the middle band?**

The three checks with weight 3 are: key events match your written list of real conversions, one submission produces one event, and the property belongs to your business with admin access on your side. A No or a Not sure on any of them keeps the result out of the top band, even when the score is 80 or higher, because the rest of the setup cannot make up for numbers you cannot trust at the base. This rule is our own definition, like the weights and thresholds.

**Where do the questions come from?**

From our published guide “A GA4 Audit You Can Finish in One Afternoon”, from the description of what we set up on our GA4 setup service page, and from our article on Consent Mode v2 and missing GA4 conversions. Where those pages give no fact, the check is worded as an action to carry out, not as a statistic.

**What does the GA4 setup service add on top of this?**

Our GA4 setup page describes a written audit of the property, with read access to GA4, Tag Manager and Ads, followed by fixes in order of impact. The page lists the audit as free with a written deliverable. A self-check cannot do that: it relies on your answers, not on the property itself.

**Can the checker tell me whether my GA4 numbers are correct?**

No. It shows where your own answers point to a gap. Only a test conversion you watch arrive, and a comparison of GA4 with your CRM, call log or orders, show whether the numbers match what happened. The checker asks whether you have done both.

## Related checkers

- [Conversion Tracking Checker](https://sterling.company/conversion-tracking-checker): Google Ads and GA4
- [Meta CAPI & Pixel Checker](https://sterling.company/meta-capi-pixel-checker): Meta Pixel and Conversions API
- [Consent Mode v2 Checker](https://sterling.company/consent-mode-v2-checker): consent signals to Google

## Read more

- Guide: [A GA4 Audit You Can Finish in One Afternoon](https://sterling.company/guides/ga4-audit)
- Article: [Consent Mode v2 and missing GA4 conversions](https://sterling.company/blog/consent-mode-v2-ga4-attribution-gap)
- Service: [GA4 setup, audit and repair](https://sterling.company/services/ga4-setup)
